Keeping talk and opinion polite on the Internet Print
Youth Column
Written by Erick Rommel, Catholic News Service   
Thursday, Apr. 23, 2015 -- 12:00 AM

The Internet is known for many things, but calm, thoughtful conversation of complex issues is not one of them. The distance between opinion and an insult aimed at a person is short.

That's why, if given the chance, I would make all Internet users follow one rule: disagree without being disagreeable.

That rule, which I try to follow, once again came to mind as I read the story of Jessica Ainscough. Doctors diagnosed her with epithelioid sarcoma, a rare form of cancer. Her initial treatment was successful, but a year later, tumors returned.

At that point, doctors recommended amputating her shoulder and arm to remove the cancer. They offered different scenarios about her chances of survival following the amputation.

Ainscough ignored the recommendation. "I didn't accept that my doctor's 'solution' was the only course of action," she wrote on her blog. "I decided that I would do everything in my power to thrive in life, in spite of the looming expiration date I'd been given."

Her actions caught public attention. Some called her the "Wellness Warrior" because she chose to pursue homeopathic treatment; others criticized her choice.

Last month, Ainscough died, and some on the Internet did what those on the Internet are prone to do: They tactlessly shared their opinions. The nicest comment I read was that "as predicted," Ainscough died of her untreated cancer. Another said that she was "dangerous." Others were more brutal. Some of the words used to talk about Ainscough were uncalled for, no matter how much a person disagreed with her choices.

No matter how public we are, in the end, our path through life is a private one. Some people don't believe in extraordinary measures. Others want every possible medical treatment. It's not possible to know every person's thought process and sharing such knowledge shouldn't be required.

Defending her doesn't mean I agree with Ainscough.

In my opinion, if you're going to voluntarily pass up modern medicine for homeopathic alternatives, then you're not trying to treat your disease. You're choosing to find comfort in your final days.

There is certain courage in that choice, but that is lessened with heated discussion and debate led by those whose opinions are formed with no knowledge of the details that led to the decision. In Ainscough's case, that's particularly true because she proved me and all the haters wrong.

Ainscough beat the survival odds doctors gave her about how long she would live without the amputation. Despite her refusal of advanced medical treatment, she lived seven years after her initial diagnosis.

If you knew your choice was seven years of painful treatment spent fighting aggressive cancer before dying or enjoying every minute of the life you had left, which would you choose? If you say the answer is easy or simple, I question your honesty.

I mourn for Ainscough and still believe in receiving the best care available from modern medicine. But maybe her death can be a learning moment for those who choose to criticize her.

None of us has all the answers, not even those who offer hurtful opinions on the Internet.

Erick Rommel is head staff writer for The Catholic Spirit in the Diocese of Metuchen, N.J. His column is syndicated through Catholic News Service.


Youth Calendar:

- View full calendar
Please support our advertisers:
About the Youth Page

How do kids your age live out their Catholic faith?

Check out this new Catholic Herald Youth Online Web page to find out!

This Web page is a place for youth in the Diocese of Madison and beyond to learn about their faith, see how others are living out their faith, and voice their own thoughts on Catholic issues.

You, too, can be a part of this Web page. Just submit articles and photos to: Catholic Herald Youth Online, 702 S. High Point Rd., Suite 121, Madison, WI 53719. If you send articles or photos via e-mail, put "Online Youth" in the subject line and send it to: info@madison   Digital photos must be in TIFF or JPEG format and at least 150 dpi.

We look forward to hearing from you!