Local/State News National/World News
The Catholic Herald: Official Newspaper of the Diocese of Madison Front page Most recent issue Past issues
July 31, 2003 Edition

 Search this site:

Bishop Speaks
You are here: Columns
About Us

Islam and democracy

photo of George Weigel
The Catholic 

George Weigel 

At a recent conference on Islam and democracy, I was privileged to meet several of the brightest Muslim scholars in America, all committed to developing an Islamic case for religious tolerance as a building block of civil society and democracy. My colleagues were men and women of courage.

Wahhabi Islam

The aggressive intolerance fostered by the Saudi-based and Saudi-funded Wahhabi form of Islam now touches many of the complex worlds of Islam in the U.S. There are things that can and cannot be done about this. That Wahhabi literature is frequently the only Islamic religious literature available in prisons is a problem that can be addressed; ditto for the dissemination of Wahhabi tracts in the armed forces.

Christian and Jewish groups should not form interfaith alliances with Islamic groups that have not put theological, political, and financial distance between themselves and the Wahhabi network. The U.S. government must re-examine its blind-eye approach to the Saudi regime's support for the international Wahhabi apparatus.

Over the long haul, the allure of Wahhabi Islam may best be countered by developing a more compelling Islamic argument for the free, prosperous, and virtuous society. What are the key questions?

Religion and state

Princeton's Bernard Lewis makes an important point when he notes that Muhammad was his own Constantine: Muhammad was both prophet and prince. Christianity, by contrast, emerged in the midst of another polity. The early Christians had to develop a Christian understanding of the Roman Empire, meaning a Christian understanding of temporal authority and a Christian understanding of the difference between society and the state.

In Islam's formative period, however, an energetic religion convinced that it was the bearer of God's final revelation had no experience of a "polity" of which it was one "part" - the religious community and the political community were one and the same. So Islam did not have to develop an idea of "polity" or "politics" in that crucial period of its existence, a period many Muslims now revere and imagine to be the Islamic ideal of the way things ought to be.

Case for pluralism

It's often said that the crucial question for Islam in its relationship to democracy is whether Muslims can articulate, from within their religious and legal traditions, a persuasive Islamic case for religious toleration, and thus for pluralism. Muslims who wish to be democrats should not have to become Enlightenment liberals in the process, relegating religious conviction to the private world.

The issue is whether faithful Muslims can construct a genuinely Islamic argument for this proposition: "It is the will of God that we be tolerant of those who hold different views about what constitutes the will of God."

That would be an important development, which the Catholic dialogue with Islam should deliberately try to nurture. (Catholics, after all, took rather a long time to evolve a Catholic case for religious freedom, and there may be something our Muslim colleagues can learn from this experience).

Key question

Another question: can Muslims make an Islamic case for politics, for the independent integrity of the political community, for a distinction between "society" and "polity" (or "state")?

According to the Second Vatican Council, "The Church, by reason of her role and competence, is not identified with any political community nor bound by ties to any political system." Could Islamic religious authorities persuasively affirm something similar? A lot of 21st century history will turn on the answer to that question.

George Weigel is a senior fellow of the Ethics and Public Policy Center in Washington, D.C.

Jump to:   Top of page

Front page           Most recent issue           Past issues

Diocese of Madison, The Catholic Herald
Offices: Bishop O'Connor Catholic Pastoral Center, 702 S. High Point Road, Madison
Mailing address: P.O. Box 44985, Madison, WI 53744-4985
Phone: 608-821-3070     Fax: 608-821-3071     E-Mail: info@madisoncatholicherald.org

Web site created by Leemark Communications.